Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Attire for Church service


Last Sunday, I was among 12-years-old Sunday School kids. They were discussing what is considered proper attire for Church Service. 

One girl said along the line that her parents asked her to wear nicely to Church so that she won't be a disgrace.

Hearing that, I wonder disgrace to who? To Jesus, who is known to approach beggars (Luke 18:35) and diseased people (Luke 17:11-19)? Or to the little girl's parents?

After the service, I saw an elder in the Church who always wear tie for the Service. So I asked him why does he do that every week. He said that because he wanted to wear his best for God. 

The little girl and the elder don on their best for Sunday Service, but both do it for different reasons.

Anyway, there is a good write-up by Duane Litfin, President of Wheaton College, on the meaning of attire to the individual as well as to the community. Seven observations are highlighted:
  1. The wearing of clothing is exclusively a human characteristic. We share many attributes with other creatures, but the inclination to clothe ourselves is not one of them. Those who know the account of Adam and Eve will understand why this is so. There is a moral and even spiritual dimension to human clothing.

  2. Our clothes serve a variety of practical, social, and cultural functions. Protection and modesty spring first to mind, but our clothes do far more. We sometimes dress to conceal or deceive. More often our clothes serve to reveal. We use clothing for decoration, for sexual attraction, for self-expression and self-assertion. By our attire we display our gender, our religion, our occupation, our social position, or causes with which we identify (e.g., sports jerseys). Our apparel may express our group membership or our role in society (e.g., company or police uniforms). Many dress to impress, while others choose the reverse: they express their rejection by intentionally flouting accepted clothing norms.

  3. Our clothing is one of our most elemental forms of communication. Long before our voice is heard, our clothes are transmitting multiple messages. From our attire, others immediately read not only such things as our sex, age, national identity, socio-economic status, and social position, but also our mood, our attitudes, our personality, our interests, and our values.

  4. We constantly make judgments about one another on the basis of clothing. Common wisdom has it that you can't judge a book by its cover. But this is only partly true; we regularly read one another's covering. What's more, we're better at it than we think. Research suggests that if you stand someone before an audience of strangers and ask them to draw inferences merely on the basis of what they see, the audience's inferences will tend toward consensus, and those inferences will tend to be more or less accurate. Why should this be? We spend our lives making judgments based on appearance and then testing those judgments in our subsequent relationships. In this way, we become rather adept at the process. Judgments based on appearance are scarcely infallible, of course, and we are wise to hold them tentatively. But it's almost impossible to avoid making them in the first place.

  5. Because our clothing is one of the fundamental ways we communicate with others, what we wear is never a purely personal matter. Our attire exerts a social influence on those around us. One famous study, for example, discovered that unwitting subjects were significantly more willing to jaywalk when following individuals wearing "high status" clothing than when following individuals wearing "low status" clothing. What we wear can shape patterns of communication around us, depending on what messages people are picking up. Consider, for example, the varied cues we send by the way we dress: "I want people to notice me." "I'm very confident." "I want to hide." "I care only about comfort." "I want to look seductive." "I repudiate you and your expectations."

  6. How we dress not only affects others; it also affects us. This dynamic is often circular: how we feel influences the clothes we put on, and the clothes we put on in turn shape how we feel. Changes of clothes can generate a change of mood; the soldier feels different in his uniform than he does in street clothes. In some settings our choice of attire can make or break us. If we like the way we look for a job interview, for instance, it will tend to strengthen our confidence. We feel better about our chances, as reflected in improved posture, more fluent speech, more dynamic gestures. On the other hand, inappropriate dress can sap our confidence. We have all experienced the uncomfortable effects of feeling under-dressed in a particular social setting.

  7. Much of the social meaning of our clothing is contextual. The appropriateness of our dress is often dictated by the situation. Dress that would send a given message in one setting might send a very different message in another. Picture, for example, a young woman dressed in hiking boots, sweatshirt, and shorts. Around a campfire the message might be, merely, "I'm ready for the trail." Choosing that same outfit for her aunt's funeral would say something rather different. Regional variations and issues of local dress loom large. Times change, values change, situations change; what was proper ten years ago may not be proper today, or vice versa.
On the other hand, there is this discussion over the appropriateness of women attire in Church. I have noticed that the most usual form this discussion takes is whether should women wear spaghetti straps, hot pants, or short skirt to Church?

Alan Noble highlighted a recent survey done on this discussion. He gives a balanced view on the expectation required from both male and female. We shall not think that it is solely the responsibility of the women to not stumble the men, as if men are merely passive victim of eccentric influence:
...honest men will admit, the stumbling threshold is relative, arbitrary, potentially very low. But I don’t think we can go to the other extreme and encourage our sisters to not care about how their appearance affects others.
To me personally, I don't have problem with spaghetti straps, hot pants, and short skirt around the Church. (If you think attire is an issue for the Church, check out Christian naturists!) So if I stumble by what others wear, that shows how fallen I am and how much spiritual formation I need to cultivate.

2 comments:

reasonable said...

Sionalhi I should start a Nudist Christian Fellowship and hopefully it will grow into a church, hehehehehehehe

onegodonemaster said...

Was interesting reading your post as I'd just tweeted this an hour ago: "The obsession with dress codes among some Malaysians disgusts me. What difference does it make if I wear a Crass tshirt and jeans or a suit?"

Your post did make me think of some of the potential 'differences', but I remain indignant about rules such as 'no round-neck t-shirts or shorts', 'smart casual only', etc.